The Narada Sting Case
A 2014 hidden-camera sting appeared to show West Bengal politicians accepting cash from an undercover reporter posing as a businessman. A CBI case followed years later, sanctioned prosecutions and dramatic 2021 arrests — but a decade on, no trial has concluded, and the case has largely stalled at the pre-trial stage.
The Promise
“Public representatives must not accept illegal gratification in exchange for official favours.”
— Standard conduct expected of elected representatives and public officials under Indian anti-corruption law, Ministers, MLAs, an MP, and a senior police officer of the West Bengal government and Trinamool Congress, as filmed in the sting · 1 January 2014
Journalist Mathew Samuel, running the news portal Narada News, conducted a sting operation in 2014 in which an undercover reporter posing as a representative of a fictitious company offered money to Trinamool Congress leaders and a police officer in exchange for purported favours, recording the transactions on hidden camera.
The Standard
That public officials would not accept cash or other gratification in exchange for official favours, as required under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and Indian Penal Code provisions on criminal conspiracy and cheating.
In force from 1 January 2014
The Reality
The sting footage was made public on 14 March 2016, days before West Bengal's assembly election, showing TMC leaders including ministers and an MP purportedly accepting cash. The Calcutta High Court ordered a CBI probe in 2017; the Supreme Court upheld that order. The CBI registered a case and, after West Bengal's Governor sanctioned prosecution in May 2021, arrested four leaders — ministers Firhad Hakim and Subrata Mukherjee, MLA Madan Mitra, and former mayor Sovan Chatterjee — on 17 May 2021, along with IPS officer S.M.H. Mirza. Their arrest triggered large protests outside the CBI's Kolkata office, including Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's own presence at a dharna there. All four were granted bail within days, first by the special CBI court and then, after prolonged wrangling over jurisdiction, confirmed by the Calcutta High Court. The CBI separately chargesheeted the accused. As of the most recent reporting reviewed, the case remains at the pre-trial stage in the special court, with the CBI's earlier bid to transfer proceedings out of the state having been rejected, and no trial verdict has been reported.
As of 1 June 2021
The Gap
Bars share a single zero-based scale. No axis truncation is used to exaggerate or minimize the gap between the two figures.
Timeline
- StatusSting operation filmed
Journalist Mathew Samuel films TMC leaders and a police officer purportedly accepting cash from an undercover reporter.
- AnnouncementSting footage made public
Narada News releases the footage days before West Bengal's assembly election, triggering a political storm.
- MilestoneCalcutta High Court orders CBI probe
The High Court directs a CBI investigation into the sting allegations.
- StatusSupreme Court affirms CBI probe
The Supreme Court declines to interfere with the CBI investigation.
- StatusGovernor sanctions prosecution
West Bengal Governor Jagdeep Dhankhar approves CBI's request to prosecute four TMC leaders.
- MilestoneCBI arrests four TMC leaders
Firhad Hakim, Subrata Mukherjee, Madan Mitra and Sovan Chatterjee are arrested; large protests follow outside CBI's Kolkata office.
- StatusCalcutta High Court confirms interim bail
After a stay-and-counter-stay dispute, the High Court grants interim bail to all four accused, with conditions including bail bonds of ₹2 lakh each.
Legal Status
The case remains pending at the pre-trial stage in a special CBI court in Kolkata. All named accused are out on bail; the CBI has filed a chargesheet, but this entry found no confirmed report of the framing of charges, start of trial, or any verdict as of the most recent sources reviewed.
Arrested May 2021; granted bail within days; case pending.
Arrested May 2021; granted bail; died in August 2021 before any trial verdict.
Arrested May 2021; granted bail; case pending.
Arrested May 2021; granted bail; case pending.
Verdict
A real sting operation, a real CBI investigation ordered by constitutional courts, and real arrests of sitting ministers took place — but this remains, a decade after the footage was filmed, an unresolved case with no trial verdict. This site reports the sting's allegations as allegations that survived judicial scrutiny to the point of a CBI chargesheet, not as proven facts; the accused have not been convicted of anything.
The High Court and Supreme Court orders directing a CBI probe, the 2021 arrests, and the bail grants are well documented in contemporaneous reporting. Confidence is not higher because this entry could not locate reporting on the case's status after mid-2021 beyond the arrest-and-bail sequence, meaning the current pre-trial status (as of 2026) is inferred from the absence of any reported trial or verdict rather than confirmed directly.
What remains incomplete
- This is a stub entry: the case's status between mid-2021 and 2026 — including whether charges have been formally framed, whether trial has begun, or whether the case has been quashed or stayed — has not been confirmed and needs updated research.
- The authenticity and unedited status of the original sting footage was disputed by some accused; this entry does not adjudicate that dispute.
- Subrata Mukherjee's death in August 2021 means the case against him has presumably abated, but this has not been separately confirmed.
Sources
Related investigations
The Amrapali Group Homebuyers Fraud
Amrapali Group took money from over 40,000 homebuyers for Noida and Greater Noida flats, then diverted thousands of crores of that money into unrelated ventures while construction stalled for years. The Supreme Court eventually cancelled the group's RERA registration and handed its projects to state-run NBCC to finish.
The Jaypee Infratech Insolvency and Homebuyers Case
Jaypee Infratech sold flats to over 20,000 homebuyers along the Yamuna Expressway, then defaulted on bank loans and entered insolvency in 2017. It took nearly seven years, a Supreme Court intervention, and two competing bidding rounds before the Suraksha Group finally took over the company in 2024 — with many buyers still waiting more than 15 years for possession.
The Unitech Group Homebuyers Fraud
Unitech collected over Rs 14,000 crore from nearly 30,000 homebuyers for flats it never finished, while a Supreme Court-ordered audit found its promoters had diverted thousands of crores abroad. The Chandra brothers spent years in jail, the government took over the company's board, and thousands of buyers are still waiting for their homes.